Elian was picked up by the us coast guard and brought to live with relatives in the miami area, sparking a lengthy legal battle over whether he should be allowed to stay in the united states. Diaz managed to secure such high levels of trust in -- and therefore access to -- the gonzalez family, that it became apparent that many of his images needed to be circulated through a pool system. The elian gonzalez issue requires us to choose between family and freedom family has been promoted by conservative christianity in the modern media as an ultimate value we find groups such as dobson's focus on the family and shlafly's eagle forum advocating the inviolability of the family. Us courts decided that elian must stay in the us until his case for asylum is heard, whether this is with his father or other guardian he cannot be taken from the us until this decision is decided or appealed. The issue of elian's return to cuba has been framed as a struggle between the political cynicism of anti-castro cuban exiles and the sweet ties of affection between father and son.
The only question i have is whether that fitness determination should have been made in a more public forum the rules provide that it does not have to be public, i am just accustomed to domestic. Should elian be trusted to such a man like his father juan lacks the abilities to provide even the basics for elian that is, food, security, justice, freedom and the right to be happy. A federal appeals court in atlanta ruled wednesday that elian gonzalez should not be removed from the united states, at least until his case is considered by the court on may 11.
So right now there's a question about whether there would be any impact if a subpoena was issued fighting for custody of elian gonzalez in the united states and the effects of the justice. Regrettably, the american people, the miami relatives of elian gonzalez and the congress still do not have all of the answers which led up to the events that transpired on that easter recess by the justice department and the immigration and naturalization service. Eight years after the furor over the repatriation of elian gonzalez to cuba possibly cost al gore the state of florida in his 537-vote loss to george w bush, the international custody saga has.
Immigration officials in miami decided that a florida state court should rule on elian's fate, a procedure that cuba rejects (and some american legal experts question. And though there was a question raised as to whether a recent court opinion, in a case known as christensen, required the court to look into the deference element, whether ins should have been able to make this kind of a decision. If the us government feels so strongly that elian should stay in the us, then they must give residency to elian's father in us and allow him to live there with his new family where he can be close to elian. Respondents were asked whether they felt the federal action to remove elian was appropriate, whether the united states government did all it could to avoid using force in this case, and whether permanent custody of elian should be granted to his father, juan miguel gonzalez, or to his relatives in miami.
Last week's 11th circuit opinion, which effectively resolves the elian gonzalez case and clears the way for young elian to be sent back to cuba, leaves us feeling a sickening sort of vindication. The question was whether the boy should continue to live with relatives in miami, florida or be sent to live with his father in cuba what was this young man's name from quiz: 15 minutes (click to play it. The question of whether elian gonzalez should be trusted in the us pages 1 words 919 view full essay more essays like this: cuba, issue of trust, elian gonzalez.
In an apparent bid to show flexibility in the campaign to return elian gonzalez to cuba, president fidel castro said the boy's father has offered to travel alone today to the united states to. So no matter how one feels about whether elian will be better or worse off back in cuba, the 11th circuit's gonzalez v reno decision is troubling for the way it handled the very separation-of-powers issue that it identified as being at the heart of the case. Elian was taken to the united states by elizabeth gonzalez without the consent or permission from juan gonzalez a short time after elian was released to the care of his uncle, lazaro gonzalez a petition for asylum was filled out by the uncle and submitted to the ins (immigration & naturalization service.
The coast guard brought elian into the united states, and the ins paroled him into the country without inspection, then released him into the custody of his great-uncle, lazaro gonzalez (lazaro) lazaro filed a petition with the ins on behalf of elian seeking political asylum for the child. Gonzalez stayed with his uncle in miami, but quickly became the center of a tug-of-war between cuba and the united states over whether he should remain in the states or be returned to his father. This week's poll garnered responses from more than 20,000 children to the question: should the us return elian gonzalez to cuba the scholastic news zone poll results to-date indicate that more than 69% of children believe that elian should remain in the united states.